Erasmus case: University staff accused of bribery
- North Macedonia
Erasmus case: University staff accused of bribery
- Case Date(s)
- 06/2016
- Case Updated
- 09/2023
Case Summary
Phase
2nd instance procedureOffence
- Bribery of public officials
- Abuse of functions
Sector
- Education
Institution
- State Economic Faculty in Skopje
Involved people
- Politically exposed
- No
- — Bribery of public officials
- — Abuse of functions
- Politically exposed
- No
- — Bribery of public officials
- — Abuse of functions
- Politically exposed
- No
- — Bribery of public officials
- — Abuse of functions
- Politically exposed
- No
- — Abuse of functions
- Politically exposed
- No
- — Bribery of public officials
- — Abuse of functions
Several professors and support staff at the at the faculty of economics at the University of St Cyril and Methodius in Skopje are accused of extorting money and sex from female students in exchange for a passing grade.
On 7 June 2016, the Ministry of Interior conducted a police operation at the faculty of economics at the University of St Cyril and Methodius located in Skopje and identified a number of employees at the faculty as suspects of bribery.
On 7 October 2016, after about four months of police investigation under the code name Erasmus, prosecutors filed charges against several individuals. Bobek Shuklev, a professor and former dean, and Slave Ristovski, also a professor, were accused of exploiting their positions and accepting bribes. Professor Dragi Janev was charged with the criminal act under the Macedonian criminal code of accepting bribes and receiving a reward for illegal influence. Additionally, professor Stojan Debarliev was accused of abuse of an official position and authority while Dragan Denkovski, an assistant, faced charges of giving bribes under the criminal code.
According to the indictment, in the period between 2015 and 2016, the accused abused their official positions to directly or indirectly solicit monetary contributions from students, ranging from €500 to €1,000, in exchange for grades they did not merit. There were documented instances of students receiving passing grades despite not having registered for the exam at all.
The bribery scheme was constructed so that, in some cases, the owner of the café located within the faculty collected money directly from the students to be handed over to the assistant, who then delivered it to the professors. Besides monetary contributions, the prosecution presented evidence of sexual extortion involving the accused professors Shuklev and Janev who, in addition to money, requested sexual favours from female students in exchange for higher grades.
The first trial for this case commenced on 30 January 2017 and lasted until 9 March 2020 when the first-instance verdict was announced with all but professor Stojan Debarliev found guilty. On 29 June 2021, the court of appeals in Skopje returned the Erasmus case for a retrial, stating that the professors were not public officials but performed activities of public interest. The trial recommenced and, during that period, one of the accused professors, Dragi Janev, passed away.
The retrial ended on 7 September 2023 with sentences being announced. Shuklev, the former dean, received a four-and-a-half-year prison sentence, which professor Ristevski received four years, and the assistant Denkovski a two-year alternative sentence of conditional imprisonment. All convicted men received a five-year ban from practicing in academia.
Further details
- JURISDICTION/COURT
Basic criminal court Skopje
- LAWS (ALLEGEDLY) BREACHED
Criminal Code: Article 358 giving a bribe and Article 357 accepting a bribe
- FINAL SANCTION OR MEASURE
4 years and 6 months prison term;
4-year prison term;
alternative sentence of conditional imprisonment for 10 months;
5-year ban from practicing their profession
- UNCOVERING METHOD
The investigation began after a report from students
- PROSECUTOR
Ivana Trajcheva
- JUDGE
Fanka Janchuleva Mihailoska
Judges Jani Niča, Tanja Mileva and Jusuf Ajrulahi in the Court of Appeal
Judge Vladimir Tufegdzic
SOCIAL HARM ON SDGs
4 Quality Education
16 Peace, justice and strong institutions
This is one of the most notorious cases in the country connected to bribery at the university level. Besides the reputational damage it has caused on the Faculty of Economics in Skopje, the affair also undermined the nation’s trust in the institutions and educational system, placing students in an unfavourable position. Significant doubts were raised in regard to the quality of the education at the faculty in question, as well as the students’ system of protection against sextortion. Moreover, the case incited a controversy in criminal legislation and how these forms of wrongdoing should be prosecuted in the future.
Disclaimer
Every effort has been made to verify the accuracy of the information contained in this database. All information is believed to be correct as of 09/2023. Nevertheless, Transparency International cannot accept responsibility for the consequences of its use for other purposes or in other contexts.
Additional Material
-
Press release Link faktor.mk/erazmus-bitka-so-profesorskata-mafija-ili-spin-da-se-pokrie-blamot-so-abolitsijataERASMUS: A battle with the professor's mafia or a spin to cover up the blam with abolition?
-
Press release Link fokus.mk/padna-presudata-za-profesorite-koi-se-tovarea-deka-barale-seks-i-mito/Conviction for Professors Accused of Soliciting Sex and Bribes Falls
-
Press release Link telma.com.mk/2023/09/07/zatvorski-kazni-za-dvajca-profesori-od-ekonomskiot-fakultet-barale-pari-i-seks-za-na-studentkite-da-im-napishat-preodna-ocenka/Prison Sentences for Two Economics Faculty Professors Demanded Money and Sex for Female Students to Write A Passing Grade
-
Press release Link jorm.gov.mk/osnovnoto-javno-obvinitelstvo-za-gon-25/Court Press Release: The Basic Public Prosecutor's Office for the Prosecution of Organised Crime and Corruption has filed an indictment against six people accused in the case known to the public as "Erasmus"
Contribute to this case
Do you have additional information, updates or relevant insights about this case? You can help by sharing new developments or legal updates on the case, providing verified sources that offer more context or evidence or highlighting public reactions or advocacy efforts related to the case.
Do you know of a corruption case that has been reported in the media or by civil society, or is already in the judicial process but is not receiving enough attention? Help us put a spotlight on key corruption cases in your country, and we will review your suggestion and consider adding it to the corruption database.
Please only suggest cases that have already been reported by the media or civil society or cases that are in some stage of the law enforcement or judicial process. If you would like to report a new corruption case, please reach out to our Advocacy and Legal Advice Centres in your country or email us.