Arben Ahmetaj Case: Deputy PM involved in incinerators concession scandal
- Albania
Arben Ahmetaj Case: Deputy PM involved in incinerators concession scandal
- Case Date(s)
- 09/2022
- Case Updated
- 08/2023
Case Summary
Phase
InvestigationOffence
- Bribery of public officials
- Illicit enrichment
- Laundering of proceeds of crime
Sector
- Water supply; sewerage, waste management and remediation activities
- Real estate activities
- Administrative and support service activities
Involved people
- Politically exposed
- No
- — Bribery of public officials
- — Laundering of proceeds of crime
- — Participated in rigging procurement process
- Politically exposed
- No
- — Bribery of public officials
- — Laundering of proceeds of crime
- — Participated in rigging procurement process
- Politically exposed
- No
- — Participated in rigging procurement process
- Politically exposed
- Yes
- — Illicit enrichment
- — Concealment
- — Laundering of proceeds of crime
- Politically exposed
- No
- — Common-law partner
- Politically exposed
- No
- — Laundering of proceeds of crime
- Politically exposed
- Yes
- — Laundering of proceeds of crime
- Politically exposed
- No
- — Laundering of proceeds of crime
- Politically exposed
- No
- — Laundering of proceeds of crime
Former Albanian deputy prime minister Arben Ahmetaj was charged in 2023 with corruption, money laundering and concealment of assets in connection with his role in the 'Incinerators Affair', a high-profile corruption scandal that shocked the country. Ahmetaj fled Albania after the special prosecutor requested his arrest, and currently remains at large, along with other key figures in the case. Over time, the scandal has implicated several high-ranking government officials and resulted in significant financial harm to Albanian taxpayers.
In 2023, Arben Ahmetaj, former deputy prime minister of Albania, was charged by the special prosecution office (SPAK) with corruption, money laundering and concealment of assets in connection with the so-called Incinerators Affair, one of the most infamous corruption scandals to rock the country in recent years. Following an arrest warrant issued by the special prosecutor, Ahmetaj fled the country and is currently a wanted fugitive.
Throughout his political career, Ahmetaj served in multiple ministerial roles under Prime Minister Edi Rama, eventually becoming deputy prime minister. In 2022, prosecutors from Albania’s special courts against corruption and organised crime (SPAK) opened an investigation into Ahmetaj’s role in the notorious Incinerators Affair. Previous investigations revealed a corruption scheme linked to three concessionary contracts awarded by the government between 2014 and 2017 for the construction of waste incinerators, ultimately to leading the arrest of former minister of environment Lefter Koka and former socialist deputy Alqi Blako.
Two concessionary companies, Albtek Energy and ITS, with no experience in urban waste processing and incineration, were granted contracts to build incinerators in Elbasan, Fier, and Tirana. Klodjan Zoto and Stela Gugallja, the nominal owners of these companies, were respectively an associate and the life partner of the controversial businessman and de facto owner, Meril Mërtiri. An investigation launched by SPAK in 2020 into the concession granted for the Elbasan incinerator revealed that the concessionary companies used ad hoc intermediary firms to funnel money to the minister of environment, Lefter Koka (see here).
Lefter Koka was arrested in December 2021 on charges of corruption and money laundering related to the 2015 concession of the Elbasan incinerator, which was awarded through an unlawful emergency procedure. In September 2023, he was sentenced to six years and eight months in prison for corruption charges linked to the Fier waste incinerator. Meanwhile, a third investigation into the waste concession in Tirana is ongoing. Other high-ranking officials have also been arrested as a result of SPAK's investigation, including former member of parliament Alqi Bllako. They are accused of corruption and money laundering and have been sentenced in absentia.
The investigation into Arben Ahmetaj and his alleged involvement in the incinerators scandal was launched in 2022. In June 2023, Ahmetaj was summoned and questioned for the first time by SPAK. The following month, Albania’s special prosecution sought to arrest Ahmetaj on charges of corruption, money laundering and falsification of official documents, i.e. asset declarations. Albania’s special prosecution requested permission from parliament to lift his immunity to arrest, but Ahmetaj fled the country before parliament voted on and accepted SPAK’s request. The special anti-corruption prosecution declared Ahmetaj as an internationally wanted person and notified Interpol.
Although all the details of the accusations are unknown, as SPAK’s chairman, Altin Dumani, stressed the need to preserve investigative secrecy, Ahmetaj was under investigation for suspected illegal benefits obtained from the two businessmen behind the waste management contracts. SPAK prosecutors claimed that Klodian Zoto and Mirel Mërtiri paid Ahmetaj at least €491,000 in bribes through intermediaries, fake real estate transactions, seaside villas and paid holidays in luxury hotels for Ahmetaj and his relatives (see here, here and here).
The investigations also revealed that in order to conceal the acquisition of a villa in a luxury resort in Hamallaj by Ahmetaj’s partner, Erjola Flamur Hoxha, Ahmetaj received assistance from businessman Gerian Kuka. Additionally, Ahmetaj was allegedly aided by his former adviser, Artan Gjoka, in the fictitious sale of villas and apartments as well as with businessmen Sokol Meqemeja and Edmond Begaj (see here and here).
Although Ahmetaj seemingly had only an indirect role in the three controversial contracts, the prosecution claims that his influence in the awarding procedure enabled the entrepreneurs to secure the concession contracts (see here).
The investigations found that Ahmetaj, through one of his employees, approved the Elbasan incinerator concession procedure (see here). The investigation files also revealed how Ahmetaj's role was decisive in the continuation of the tender for the Tirana incinerator, currently under investigation (see here and here).
After the failed attempt to arrest him, SPAK seized properties belonging to Ahmetaj as well as documents of interest, laptops, mobile phones and USB drives found in these properties. Additionally, two bank accounts belonging to Ahmetaj, totalling €124,300, were also seized.
Data from the investigation shows that Ahmetaj had a close relationship with Mirel Mërtiri, at least since 2012 (see here). According to BIRN’s findings, Mërtiri, who is currently also on the run, built a business empire with companies registered in Albania and in offshore jurisdictions under the names of close associates. Ahmetaj, currently a fugitive in Switzerland, denied having any role in the waste treatment contracts and has repeatedly called the investigation against him political revenge (see here). However, Koka told BIRN that several ministries were involved, including the finance ministry, led by Ahmetaj at the time. Recently, Ahmetaj has employed a US lobbying company to persuade the US government that the charges against him are false. In addition to the high-profile incinerators affair, Ahmetaj has faced other investigations and corruption allegations (see here).
The three concessions have cost Albanian taxpayers at least €150 million, based on BIRN’s calculations, and estimates from Albania’s supreme audit institution suggest they could cost taxpayers €430 million over the next 30 years. Consequently, the social harm caused by the misuse of public resources was enormous.
PULLOUT (highlight) text here
Further details
- JURISDICTION/COURT
Special prosecution for corruption and organised crime; first instance special court for corruption and organised crime
- LAWS (ALLEGEDLY) BREACHED
The criminal code Article 257/a second paragraph (‘Refusal to declare, non-declaration, concealment, or false declaration of assets, private interests of elected officials and public employees, or any other person with a legal obligation to declare’),
Article 25 (‘In cooperation’),
Article 260 (‘Passive corruption of high state officials or local elected officials’),
Article 287 second paragraph (‘Cleaning of the criminal offence or criminal activity products’)
- UNCOVERING METHOD
State audit institution, compliance audit by directorate of concessions, ministry of finance and economy, December 2019.
State audit institution, performance audit report ‘Incinerator of Tirana’, January 2022.
Ministry of Finance and Economy, annual summary report on the performance of concession contracts and public private partnerships, 2019
Ministry of Finance and Economy, annual summary report on the performance of concession contracts and public private partnerships, 2020.
Ministry of Finance and Economy, annual summary report on the performance of concession contracts and public private partnerships, 2021.
Ministry of Finance and Economy, annual financial inspection report, 2020.
- PROSECUTOR
Prosecutors of the special prosecution
First prosecutor to the case was Klodian Braho.
Based on the decision of special prosecution head Altin Dumani, prosecutor Klodian Braho was substituted at his request and the case was passed on to a prosecutor group led by Altin Dumani and second chair prosecutor Enkeleda Millonai.
- JUDGE
Erjon Bani
- DEFENCE COUNSEL
Ardian Visha
Henrik Ligori
SOCIAL HARM ON SDGs
3 Good health and well-being
10 Reduced Inequality
9 Industry, innovation and infrastructure
6 Clean Water and Sanitation
Audit reports and media investigations reveal that the Albanian government has paid €70.2 million (including VAT; exchange rate: lek/euro 106) for the Elbasan and Fier incinerators. However, the incinerator in Elbasan is in poor working condition, requiring repairs for almost half of the year, while the one in Fier remains incomplete despite deadline extensions. The contract for the incinerator in Tirana is in a similar state; the company has invested only in the expansion of the landfill while the incinerator build has been delayed. The state budget has so far covered €63 million euros (including VAT) of the cost. These setbacks undermine Albania's efforts to modernise waste management, potentially worsening environmental pollution and public health risks.
The waste of public funds has dramatically damaged the state budget and harmed taxpayers' interests. Consequently, the misuse of funds allocated for critical infrastructure projects erodes public trust in government institutions. When high-ranking officials are implicated, citizens may perceive the entire political system as corrupt. Additionally, the perception that influential individuals can evade justice undermines the credibility of anti-corruption initiatives and judicial reforms in the country.
Furthermore, the abovementioned public funds could have been directed to improve education, healthcare and infrastructure. Further investment in these areas could improve social inequities, as the most vulnerable populations bear the brunt of inefficient public services.
The binding of public tenders and markets to the same individuals in business damages innovation and hinders the development of the waste management industry.
Contribute to this case
ContributeDisclaimer
Every effort has been made to verify the accuracy of the information contained in this database. All information is believed to be correct as of 08/2023. Nevertheless, Transparency International cannot accept responsibility for the consequences of its use for other purposes or in other contexts.
Additional Material
-
Press release Link www.reporter.al/2023/07/18/dosja-ahmetaj-spak-sekuestron-4-apartamente-dhe-dy-llogari-bankare/"Ahmetaj" file, SPAK seizes 4 apartments and two bank accounts
-
Press release Link www.reporter.al/2023/07/18/fundjavat-e-luksit-te-arben-ahmetajt-me-parate-e-incineratoreve/Arben Ahmetaj's luxury weekends with the money of the incinerators
-
Press release Link www.reporter.al/2023/10/11/privatizoi-toke-me-cmimet-e-vitit-94-merret-serish-i-pandehur-arben-ahmetaj/He privatized land at the prices of '94, the defendant Arben Ahmetaj is taken again
-
Press release Link www.reporter.al/2023/07/13/kuvendi-vendos-te-votoje-te-premten-per-arrestimin-e-ahmetajt/The Assembly decides to vote on Friday for Ahmetaj's arrest
-
Press release Link balkaninsight.com/2024/06/26/albanian-businessman-bankrolling-fugitive-ex-deputy-pm-prosecutors-claim/Albanian Businessman Bankrolling Fugitive Ex-Deputy PM Prosecutors Claim
Contribute to this case
Do you have additional information, updates or relevant insights about this case? You can help by sharing new developments or legal updates on the case, providing verified sources that offer more context or evidence or highlighting public reactions or advocacy efforts related to the case.
Do you know of a corruption case that has been reported in the media or by civil society, or is already in the judicial process but is not receiving enough attention? Help us put a spotlight on key corruption cases in your country, and we will review your suggestion and consider adding it to the corruption database.
Please only suggest cases that have already been reported by the media or civil society or cases that are in some stage of the law enforcement or judicial process. If you would like to report a new corruption case, please reach out to our Advocacy and Legal Advice Centres in your country or email us.