Models of donor coordination for managing multi-donor inputs

Filed under - Poverty and development

Published on 30 October 2017 as a U4 Helpdesk answer
We are spearheading an international initiative that aims to strengthen the technical assistance provision structures for anti-money laundering and the combatting of illicit financial flows that are an important driver of international corruption. We wish to draw on the experiences of donor coordination practices in providing technical assistance for anti-corruption purposes. What does the evidence of these practices tell us about which coordination structures are most effective for managing multi-donor inputs for delivering technical assistance?

Content

  1. Background
  2. Problem statement
  3. Typology of coordination measures
  4. Challenges of donor coordination for anticorruption
  5. Options for donor coordination on anti-money laundering and illicit financial flows
  6. References

Caveats

This paper surveys forms of donor coordination to determine which are the most promising for development agencies looking to make headway against money laundering and illicit financial flows. It is worth nothing that these kind of anticorruption interventions remain the exception for most donors as the majority of aid-funded anticorruption programming continues to focus on bureaucratic and petty corruption, or seeks to strengthen civil society’s ability to hold governments to account. Targeting money laundering and illicit financial flows is likely to require very different, and as yet largely untested, forms of donor coordination which may require the prioritisation of reform at home over interventions abroad. Furthermore, while there is a sizeable literature on general donor coordination, the evidence base on coordination mechanisms in the anti-corruption field is limited. Where studies exist, they tend to either focus on joint donor support to public financial management reforms, or donors’ collective responses to corruption scandals in the country of operation, rather than dedicated anti-corruption interventions. Finally, there is little empirical evidence in terms of the transaction costs of donor coordination on governance issues.

Summary

Where the delivery of development assistance is fragmented and donor agencies’ activities lack coordination, transaction costs are likely to be exorbitant and the proliferation of parallel service delivery structures undermines both the efficacy and legitimacy of the recipient state’s institutions. In the area of anti-corruption, inconsistencies in donor approaches entail additional challenges, such as enabling recipient governments to jettison muchneeded governance reforms. Although experts have been calling for greater coordination between donors on anti-corruption work for over two decades, progress has been slow and considerable structural constraints remain. These barriers range from the prosaic – development agencies’ differing reporting and funding cycles – to the pathological – instinctive bureaucratic competition. This query surveys various modalities of donor coordination, grouped into three broad categories: funding, information sharing and international engagement. It then considers which forms of donor coordination lend themselves to initiatives designed to tackle sophisticated forms of corruption, such as money laundering and illicit financial flows. A review of the available literature suggests that coordination structures, such as multi-donor trust funds, may facilitate joint approaches in recipient countries, while information-sharing vehicles, such as the OECD’s Anti-Corruption Task Team, could foster high-level dialogue without fixating on the harmonisation of donors’ policies and procedures.

Author(s): Matthew Jenkins, Transparency International tihelpdesk@transparency.org
Reviewed by: Roberto Martinez B. Kukutschka and Marie Chêne, Transparency International
Publication date: 30 October 2017
Number: 0

Download full answer

Country / Territory - International   
Region - Global   
Language(s) - English   
Tags - Donors   |   Multilateral and bilateral donor agencies   |   Donor aid   |   donor coordination   |   OECD Anti-Corruption Task Team   |   Nordic plus   |   multi-donor trust funds   |   MDTFs   

Contact the Anti-Corruption Helpdesk

If you work for one of our supporting partner organisations, submit your query to the Helpdesk:
tihelpdesk@transparency.org

More Helpdesk answers

23
Apr
2009

Developing a code of conduct for NGOs

Do you have any information on codes of conduct for civil society organizations? See the answer

15
Dec
2014

Fighting Judicial Corruption Topic Guide

Could you please provide a topic guide about fighting judicial corruption?See the answer