Red card: Time to expel corruption from the game
Corrupting the game
Playing corrupt
Transparency in sport is crucial
Interview with investigative journalist Jens Weinreich
Selected links
Media coverage
Corrupting the game
The underlying principle of sport is the commitment to solidarity, respect, impartiality and fair play. When more than a hundred years ago the Olympic Movement was initiated, its founders dreamed of educating youth through sport for a better world without any kind of discrimination. The International Olympic Committee (IOC) was one of the first global civil society movements formed to achieve this aim. However as more financial resources have flown into sports since those times the Olympics have come to resemble any other commercial activity, where money and influence play a crucial importance replacing, on many occasions, the principle of fair competition.
The sport world has responded slowly and, to date, inadequately. It is as serious a threat as doping; only it has the potential to inflict much greater damage on the sport world and the communities, representing billions of people globally, that support it.
Corruption has been recognised as one of the biggest threats to modern sport which fundamentally undermines all Olympic ideals. Bribing arbiters and decision-makers, betting scandals, corruption in procurement systems and construction of sport infrastructure, sponsors trying to influence sporting decisions as well as the existence of secret doping networks, demonstrate a wide range of possibilities for corruption in sports. Not only does corruption turn the game into a deception of rivals, it deceives primarily the audience and destroys the dreams of millions of fans.
Playing corrupt
|
|
Bribery scandals involving individual sportspeople or referees across the globe regularly make headlines in the media. Moreover corruption cases of a larger scale, concerning international sport associations and organisations, which often operate huge sums of money, have a negative impact on the perception of sport ethics in general. |
In 2002, for instance, the IOC’s reputation and credibility have been overshadowed by vote-buying accusations in the bidding process for the Games in Salt Lake City. As a consequence some members of the Committee were expelled or resigned but there has never been a conviction.
The rise in popularity of the online sports betting services has opened up a new leeway for corruption and match-fixing. Thus the true competition of the encounter is ruined by financial incentive given for losing against a weaker rival.
The ways of corrupting sport practices are numerous and in the absence of clear legislation for tackling corruption, offenders can easily get away unscathed. Investigations and convictions often prove inadequately trivial comparing to the gravity and scale of the corrupt manipulations, which are then justified as a necessary procedure. The organisation Play the Game suggests that there is a need for “a rulebook that ensures sports leaders can be sentenced with similar penalties to the ones they impose on the athletes.”
An unprecedented scandal in sport involving millions of euros ended with only three minor convictions.
In March 2008, the Swiss court produced evidence that in the period from 1989 to 2001 International Sport and Leisure company (ISL) paid officials from a number of sports federations 87.5 million euros in exchange for profitable broadcasting rights. However six former ISL executives indicted in this case were cleared of most of the charges for insufficient evidence that the payments were bribery.
Source: Play the Game
Transparency in sport is crucial
Sport is lagging behind in recent advances to achieve transparency by other sectors. While business principles, good governance and corporate social responsibility are on the agenda of big international companies, it is still not the case with the IOC and the Olympic Games.
A new coalition against corruption in sports is needed to gather sports organisations on the one hand and the global anti-corruption civil society movement on the other. It is crucial that corruption in sports be prevented and whenever it takes place, exposed and adequately addressed within the legal framework.
A first step: sports organisations should clearly state their disapproval of and intention to fight criminal manipulation. Such a move would send out a signal to potential criminals and can prompt people who suspect corruption somewhere in the chain to report it.
Sport is an integral part of our world and its aversion to corruption must be brought to the fore of the international debate. Everyone should join efforts to communicate that corruption in sports is unacceptable. Key stakeholders in this process include sport organisations, the media, sponsors, governments, civil society and, more importantly, sport fans.
The global movement of TI is working towards achieving this goal. In 2006 TI Germany established a working group on sport and corruption issues managing to raise awareness and bring the issue to the international level.
In its Global Corruption Report 2007 TI shows the danger of judicial partiality when it comes to the most popular national game football.
“Recently, a member of a special court appointed to investigate football managers and referees involved in rigging matches in the prestigious ‘Serie A’ league openly told a newspaper that its decision had taken into account Italy’s victory in the 2006 World Cup, a spate of popular demonstrations and the support of some mayors of the cities whose teams were most implicated. It is certainly not illegal to express an opinion, participate in a public demonstration or, obviously, to win a World Championship. But whatever the judge may have meant about why he acted as he did, it is not correct for a judge to decide on the existence and gravity of an unlawful behaviour with reference not only to the rules, but to popular opinion, public protest and national pride.”
From GCR 2007: Corruption in Judicial Systems, p. 107
|
|
As the world watches the 2008 Olympics in Beijing it is a good time not to overlook corruption as we indulge in the glory of the games. Already a symbol of China’s emergence on the world stage the 2008 Games pose a challenge for the Olympic Movement to make integrity a key player. |
Interview with investigative journalist Jens Weinreich
|
Prominent German sports journalist Jens Weinreich provides insights into corruption in the sport world and its synergies with criminal structures. |
|
Selected links
TI In Focus: Corruption and Sport (2006)
Transparency Watch: spotlight story (June 2006)
Transparency in Sport
Play the game
FIFA Code of Ethics
IOC Ethics Commission
TI Germany sports section (in German)
China: Olympics Harm Key Human Rights (Human Rights Watch)
Media coverage
So korrupt ist das IOC
Cicero, 08 August 2008
Fears of corruption as UK alone could gamble £25m on Beijing Olympics
The Telegraph, 08 August 2008
L Monika case shocks State
The Sangai Express, 06 August 2008
AL | Yankees' Dominican scouts facing scrutiny
Seattle times, 05 August 2008
Das „System Emig“ vor Gericht
Focus, 02 August 2008
Russia Will Address Doping Bans After the Games
The New York Times, 02 August 2008
The Big Question: What are betting exchanges, and do they lead to corruption?
The Independent, Opinion, 01 August 2008
Bestechungsversuch im Doping-Labor
Frankfurter Rundschau, 30 July 2008
Racing's Dirty Secrets
BBC, 30 July 2008
Officials accused of match fixing
Namibian, 23 July 2008
Secrets in the Blood
BBC, July 21 2008
Harry Redknapp corruption probe: Two-year inquiry that strikes at the heart of football
The Observer, 13 July 2008
Pressure Building for Draft of Players From Outside U.S.
The New York Times, 13 July 2008
Sporting bodies struggle to match challenge of betting
The Guardian, 30 October 2007
International Soccer Tarnished by Corruption Case
Spiegel, 29 February 2008
home
print this page